052 – Frankie and Johnny

We’re going all the way back to 1991 for this week’s episode on Gary Marshall’s take on the Terrence McNally two-hander Frankie and Johnny. Here is a film that was a convergence of several Oscar narratives: Al Pacino’s lengthy overdue status, Michelle Pfeiffer’s prestige ascent, and Marshall’s follow-up to the success of Pretty Woman. The film works overtime to open up the play’s text, and results in a film about two lonely New Yorkers that we kind of actually like. But despite the pedigree and an Academy willing to even nominate Pacino for Dick Tracy the previous year, Oscar looked elsewhere. Pfeiffer was also criticized for being too glamorous for the character, and notably turned down the role that would win Best Actress this year: The Silence of the Lambs’ Clarice Starling. And the film has further hooks on the fringes of the ‘91 Oscar year: Kate Nelligan shared a few notable critics prizes with this and The Prince of Tides, the film she would ultimately be nominated for. This week, we also discuss the last days of Johnny Carson, Pfeiffer and Pacino’s lack of nominations past the early 90s, and Terence Trent D’Arby. Follow Us on Twitter! @Had_Oscar_Buzz Joe: @joereid Chris: @chrisvfeil